Cricket Scotland is once again under the microscope as it launches a formal investigation into historical tweets by Khizar Ali, a current board member. Ali, who joined the board in May 2023, is alleged to have posted derogatory tweets back in 2012 that included racially offensive language aimed at Pakistanis and Indians.
A Troubled Past Resurfacing
The controversy erupted after screenshots of Ali's old tweets emerged, causing outrage within the cricketing and South Asian communities. Ali used the offensive "P" word multiple times, a term widely recognized as racially insensitive, especially in reference to Pakistanis. In response to the revelations, Ali issued a public apology:
"There were recent screenshots shared of historic tweets from 2012 where I used the P word. The reading of the word in full for some within the South Asian and cricketing communities will invoke and trigger upset. To anyone who has to read that and it caused upset, I want to extend my sincere apologies to you."
Despite Ali’s apology, the fallout has been significant. Running out Racism, an organization committed to eradicating racism in cricket, has called for an urgent and thorough investigation. A spokesperson expressed their disappointment:
"Running out Racism members are surprised, dismayed and feel incredibly let down that someone we've a huge amount of respect for would use such words, in any context, at any point in history. This has caused upset and anger with some we support and represent, it is difficult at this stage to work beyond how people feel in the immediate term. However, we do acknowledge Khizar’s willingness to proactively own this, and appreciate the conversations he's engaged in directly with us and many others regarding these messages."
Cricket Scotland's Commitment to Change
This incident comes on the heels of a significant overhaul within Cricket Scotland. Last year, an independent investigation uncovered 448 instances of institutional racism in the governance of the sport, prompting a complete restructuring of the board. Cricket Scotland has since committed to creating an inclusive environment and eradicating all forms of discrimination. A spokesperson for Cricket Scotland emphasized their dedication:
"The board of Cricket Scotland was completely changed last year after an independent investigation found the governance of the game in Scotland to be institutionally racist. We are committed to ensuring that our sport is safe, welcoming, inclusive, and open to all. We are determined to adopt a zero-tolerance approach to racism, sexism, and all forms of unacceptable behaviour."
While Cricket Scotland strives to distance itself from past controversies, the resurfacing of Ali's old tweets poses challenging questions about the vetting process for board members and the efforts to maintain a genuinely inclusive culture.
Ali’s Involvement with Anti-Racist Initiatives
Ironically, Khizar Ali has been involved with Running out Racism, further complicating the narrative. Ali defended himself by stating:
"There are also various other tweets which are being shared out of context of the conversation they sit within, and I am willing to commit to any discussions directly with anyone who has any concerns on these, as I have already with a number of colleagues."
This statement indicates Ali's readiness to engage in ongoing discussions and address concerns directly, a move that has received mixed reactions. While some appreciate his willingness to confront the issue head-on, others remain skeptical of his past behavior.
The Path Forward
The situation places Cricket Scotland in a precarious position as it seeks to balance accountability with the progress made over the past year. The governing body must navigate the repercussions of Ali's historic tweets while sustaining its commitment to an inclusive and discrimination-free environment.
As the investigation unfolds, the cricketing community will be watching closely, hoping to see tangible actions and resolutions. Whether this incident will strengthen Cricket Scotland's resolve to combat racism or hinder its recent progress remains to be seen.